Honest comparison
Solid roof upgrade vs full extension
If your existing conservatory feels unusable, you have two options: replace just the roof, or knock the whole thing down and build an extension. Here's the honest comparison — cost, time, planning and resale.
| Factor | Solid roof upgrade | Full extension |
|---|---|---|
| Typical cost | £6,500 – £15,000 | £35,000 – £80,000+ |
| Time on site | 4 – 7 days | 10 – 16 weeks |
| Planning permission | Usually permitted development | Often required |
| Building Regs | Part L + Part A | Full new-build regs |
| Disruption to home | Minimal — conservatory only | Significant — kitchen/garden access |
| Resale value uplift | Treated as true extension | Higher absolute value, much higher cost |
| Reuses existing structure | Yes — frame & base stay | No — full demolition & rebuild |
| Best for | Existing conservatory needing comfort | Adding new floor space |
Which is better value?
For most homeowners with an existing conservatory, a solid roof upgrade is dramatically better value. You spend roughly a fifth of the cost, finish in days rather than months, avoid most of the disruption, and end up with a fully usable insulated room that valuers treat as proper extension space. A full new-build extension only makes sense if you genuinely need more square footage or the existing conservatory base is structurally beyond saving.
Free survey · No pressure
Talk to a Smart-Roof specialist
Free survey, fixed written quote, no pressure.